00. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. angus) 14 With bacon, sautéed onion, cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce haddock (broiled or fried) 16 Served with fries and coleslaw crab cakes 23 Served with fries and coleslaw fried fishermans platter 28 Specialties: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Page · Seafood Restaurant. Castaways on the Island is an American restaurant located in La Crosse. 3. Castaways on the Lake: Local Hangout with Views of Lake Ontario & Irondequoit Bay - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways On The Lake « Back To Webster, NY. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Open now : 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM. Take a break & enjoy the sunshine at Castaways on the Lake today! ☀. Could go in for a lengthier review but in a nutshell: not a knowledgeable staff (bartender could not tell Scotch from Bourbon), poorly stocked bar, deck eating area did not appear very clean with dirty. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. WE HAVE SEVERAL MENUS FOR YOU TO ENJOYDEPENDING ON WHEN YOU VISIT US. or t'ree! The Phantom Lake setting is gorgeous and the bar/restaurant is inviting and warm. Contact the restaurant for the most up to date information. 1603 N. The place was clean. 585-323-2943 244 Lake Road Webster, NY 14580. 00 Topped with fresh. The place overlooks the lake and has a relaxing vibe. 16 Fried Calamari. Call Today! Webster Castaways On The Lake View Menus Read Reviews Write Review Directions Castaways On The Lake ($$) 3. Castaways on the Lake: Expensive. 244 Lake Rd Webster NY 14580. Castaways on the Lake: Worst meal I've ever had - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. See all 37 photos. (585) 323-2943 Visit Website Map & Directions 244 Lake RdWebster, NY 14580. Castaways on the Lake: Impressed - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar. The Castaways, formerly known as the Sandbar Inn. Webster. Lorene Burandt Ms. Improve this listing. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Webster Vacation Packages Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Dinner in Bar Area - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Cast Away Lakes - The Perfect Catfish Fishing Get Away Where Fishing Memories Are Made. Top Restaurants in Tomahawk. Castaways on the Lake. 302 S Center St. castaway’s burger $15 served on a hawaiian bun with grilled pineapple, lettuce tomato, pickle, cheddar cheese, bacon & an onion ring drizzled with wang bang sauce. Page · Seafood Restaurant. Share. Website. Outdoor seating. Rochester's best know waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. . +1 585-323-2943. 00. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: worst lunch ever - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Island is an American restaurant located in La Crosse. A menu full of divine options will fulfill the heart’s true cravings. 2017. . Dominic's at the Lake / Restaurant, Italian, Pub & bar #164 of 3746 places to eat in Rochester. Save. Ranked #37 of 104 Restaurants in Webster. September 2023. 759. Castaways on the Lake: Ok. Castaways, Chicago: See 40 unbiased reviews of Castaways, rated 3. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #38 of 90 restaurants in Webster. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. Castaways River Tiki Bar; View Menus; Read Reviews; Write Review; Directions; Photos; Castaways River Tiki Bar ($$) 4. 8 a. 27 reviews #1,019 of 2,107 Restaurants in Orlando $$ - $$$ American Bar Pub. Cuisine: Seafood. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 92 restaurants in Webster. “ Always fabulous ” 09/08/2022. Rochester's best known waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. The view was out of this world. Closed now : See all hours. The food was okay, and the service was kinda slow. +1 585-323-2943. Tomorrow: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm. Tomorrow: 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. and not much else - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in both Spring and Summer. - See 322 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Castaways on the Lake: Perfect food, wine and views! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake in Webster, NY 14580 is a waterfront restaurant & bar that offers great views while enjoying local favorite meals. comCastaways Restaurant Bar & Grill: Don’t go zooming by! - See 145 traveler reviews, 25 candid photos, and great deals for Astor, FL, at Tripadvisor. Everything is homemade and amazing. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. • $$ • American • Burgers • Sandwiches. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Share. Castaways on the Lake: Terrible experience! - See 322 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Boat Docking. •. The Castaway Club on Lake Alexander, Cushing: See 34 unbiased reviews of The Castaway Club on Lake Alexander, rated 3. 1575 Florida 40. +1 585-323-2943. 69 photos. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful sunset view - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Nice view but food could be better - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. or even the restaurant itself. We have a protected marina, private beach, The Home of Gene Miller Guide Service. Rochester Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in. m. Description: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Description: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Ranked #37 of 103 Restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 324 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #37 of 88 restaurants in Webster. 3 Stars - 26 Votes Select a Rating! View Menus 244 Lake Rd Webster, NY 14580 (Map & Directions) (585) 323-2943 Cuisine: Seafood, American, Steakhouse Neighborhood: Webster Website: Leaflet | © OSM Details CUISINES Bar, Seafood Meals Lunch, Dinner, Late Night FEATURES Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Takeout, Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Parking Available, Free off-street parking, Television, Wheelchair Accessible, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Accepts Discover, Accepts Credit Cards, Table Service, Waterfront Castaways on the Lake, Webster (town), New York. Castaways on the Lake: Late dinner - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #41 of 92 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake: Plan on waiting - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. CASTAWAYS. 15 reviews #1,214 of 2,108 Restaurants in Orlando $$ - $$$ American Bar Pub. Castaways on the Lake: View of the lake sitting on the deck at sunset can forgive the culinary dullness - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. The service also deserves a 4 or 5. He points to a new. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 324 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #36 of 88 restaurants in Webster. Phone: 585-265-3850. •. Castaways on the Lake: On the low side of average - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Enjoy catering services from Castaways on the Lake in Webster, NY 14580 at your next party or event! Call us now! 585-323-2943 244 Lake Road Webster, NY. We ended up having a great appetizer and shared a pizza. . They also provide catering. 00. Mouth watering good. Webster. Webster, NY 14580. (585) 323-1224. Sort by: Global Friends You. With crumbled bleu cheese, bacon, hard boiled egg, black olives, tomato, cucumber, red onion in a red wine vinaigrette. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Castaways on the Lake: Was there with 3 friends had a very bad meal food quality was poor service was very bad and the prices were way to high - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Check-in Add. On Norris Lake in LaFollette, Tennessee, there is a full-service marina called Shanghai Resort. - Filmed With One Camera Angle - Rugby. m. Rating · 4. During the Summer weekend. Castaways On The Lake / Seafood, Restaurant, Pub & bar #735 of 3746 places to eat in Rochester. Outdated menu here? Click to update. amazing views!!! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Be a guest at your next party and let us do the cooking. Their restaurant, Castaways, is available for lunch and supper seven days a week. m. Page 1 of 6. Review of Castaways on the Lake. 1 Stars - 7 Votes. Castaways On The Lake | 3 followers on LinkedIn. Select a Rating! View Menus. Castaways on the Lake: Deserves no points. Combination of all our veggies served on a bed of greens. 1707 N 4th St Chillicothe, IL 61523. Webster. Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Comfort food, Happy hour drinks, Happy hour food, Hard liquor, Kids' menu, Small plates, Wine Dining options : Lunch, Dinner, Catering, Dessert,. Mr. Castaway Craig’s Pub & Grub. Whether you’re just stopping in for a fruity and refreshing cocktail, are craving some chips and guacamole or want to enjoy one of our great burgers, Castaways has something for everyone! Take a look at our Grill Menu to see all of our lunch and dinner options, or browse our Drink Menu to try one of our beach cocktails. have partnered together to open Castaway Craig’s Pub & Grub, a family restaurant with a beach inspired atmosphere on the beautiful shore of Craig Beach, Ohio. 29 Coconut. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful Setting - See 320 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: View - amazing; food - awful! - See 320 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways On The Lake. “Good food, service and location. 25131 Blackwater Lane. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in both. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #55 of 103 restaurants in Webster. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to Webster Castaways on the Lake;Castaways on the Lake: Good food! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #38 of 90 restaurants in Webster. My wife and I shared a burger, fries, and some cheese curds! Hot and. 324 Reviews. Share it with friends or find your next meal. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. 69 photos. 27 Baked Salmon with a cucumber dill sauce. Our establishment has been serving the Rochester area since 1906. Webster. Mendon Music Festival. The secluded little island of Threa, to the south west, can offer powerful defenses where steep mountains form a ring around Witcheye lake. IN BUSINESS. Specialties: Kenny's Castaways Italian Restaurant in Montauk, New York, delights with its exquisite cuisine, inviting ambiance, and impeccable. . Rochester's best known waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. OH. Warm evenings and daily specials are what make the Castaways a favorite dining destination. Serving mouth-watering. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 92 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake: Fine waterfront dining - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake. “Good food, service and location. Dine on tasty appetizers, sandwiches, fresh salads and refreshing desserts. Castaways on Mille Lacs. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. 4. F. 1603 N Lake Shore Dr, Chicago, IL 60614 (773) 281-1200 Visit Website. Rochester's best known waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. 00 Egg battered, sauteed with sherry lemon, butter Bruschetta Bread $7. Seafood, American, Steakhouses $$$$. (315) 668-3434. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #38 of 87 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake. Share. (1600N, 200E) Chicago, IL 60614. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful View of Lake Ontario! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Serving. 69 photos. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Castaways On The Lake restaurant Webster 14580. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to Webster Castaways on the Lake; Things to Do in WebsterCastaways on the Lake: Save your money - One star for the view alone - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Really Good Food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Not impressed, won't be back - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. You 0. Castaways on the Lake: View - Yes, Food - Not so much - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful Sunset and Good Food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. You feel like your on vacation there! Especially with the great white shark hanging on the wall, fun. 3 Stars - 26 Votes Select a Rating! View Menus 244. . Elizabeth Carpenter Castaways on the Lake Restaurant Century Liquor and Wines Dr. Castaways on the Lake: Great location - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. I would give Castaways a 5 for its location on Lake Ontario. Most beer gardens offer a view of the surrounding brick walls, the sites and sounds of the nearest. For availability and rates, call 352. Webster. Check-out time 10 a. 324 Reviews. The food was great-super tasty fries and Cole slaw as well as the fish tacos. The Lakes Restaurant, Victoria, British Columbia. Castaways. Fish Broiled Haddock with lemon and butter. - See 319 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 5. 2114 Grandview • Lake Milton, OH 44429. Improve this listing. Castaways on the Lake: Great setting. Improve this listing. Italian, Vegetarian options $$$$This awesome little restaurant, blocks from Lake Erie, is definitely a new favorite place. 1600 Portland Ave near E. Castaways On The Lake restaurant Webster location. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to WebsterCastaways On The Lake Castaways On The Lake > Menu Menus: | Menu | Web Menu | Update Menu. Webster. Serving. Karen Conte Ms. Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. $0 - $20. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. Boston Cold Plate $14. The Lakes Restaurant is a local favorite, known for. 504 N Alafaya Trl Suite 102, Orlando, FL 32828-4367 +1 407-377-5895 Website Menu. No matter when you visit us lunch, happy hour, dinner or late night you will find a. We have a two tiered lakeside dining deck that offers the perfect setting for outdoor dining, in both Spring and Summer. Castaways on the Lake: a view doesn't make a restaurant! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Fax: 352. Website. Castaways on the Lake: Overall just an okay experience. View the Menu of Castaways on the Lake in 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY. 309-274-3484. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful setting, great menu, and great service - See 322 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Lake County. Ridge Rd. 03 mi. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful setting - See 324 traveler reviews, 69 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways River Tiki Bar in Eastlake Ohio serves food and drinks on the Chagrin River and has direct boater access and tie off available. Serving both drinks. Castaways on the Lake: Food was not very good especially for the price - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. 244 Lake Rd. 16 Chicken Wings 10 wings served either sweet and sour or buffalo…. The only bar and restaurant on the lake. Lousy food and service - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. $0 - $20. Description: Gorgeous views of the sunsets on Lake Ontario all while enjoying our fine casual dining outside from steaks to the very freshest seafood. Rochester's best know waterfront restaurant for over 85 years. Ranked #37 of 103 Restaurants in Webster. 39 reviews. Phone: (440) 510-8508. $0 - $20. See restaurant menus, reviews, ratings, phone number, address, hours, photos and maps. Webster Castaways On The Lake View Menus Read Reviews Write Review Directions Castaways On The Lake ($$) 3. About Castaways at Hidden Harbor. +1 585-323-2943. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to Webster Castaways on the Lake;Castaways on the Lake: Go for the view, not the food. Castaways on the Lake: We were satisfied - See 320 traveler reviews, 68 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Specialties: Make A Reservation through our website to save your seat. Webster Tourism Webster HotelsCastaways on the Lake: A great place to visit in the summertime along the lake. Castaways on the Lake: Great view; attentive service; marginal food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. +1 585-323-2943. Add Check-in. +1 585-323-2943. Nav Menu 2. Castaways on the Lake: It's not the Ritz - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Great View and Good Food - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. More restaurant details. Castaways on the Lake: Nice view of lake - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: Great seafood, setting, service and sunset! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Buffalo Sabres Hockey Team Ms. Mille Lacs Lake offers some of the finest walleye fishing in North America. ( 562 Reviews ) Add Your Business. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #39 of 91 restaurants in Webster. 1603 N. Providing a destination location for boaters along the shore of Lake Erie. Certainly worth the 40 minute drive from our camp at Pymatuning. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #41 of 93 restaurants in Webster. Castaways on the Lake: Best Lake Views in a casual setting, grab a cold drink and enjoy the view! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways on the Lake: This is a hidden jem of a place. - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. (773) 281-1200) There are few things in Chicago that are better than being at the lakefront in the summertime, especially when you’re having a margarita at Castaways Bar & Grill. Nav Menu 3. N/A IBU (3. About. Lake Puketi 2683, Auckland, New Zealand +64 9 236 5041. Castaways on the Lake: Done with this place - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. More. The menu is amazing! I'm a vegetarian and my husband loves a good burger. Nav Menu 5. Price range: $0 - $20. CASTAWAYS. Castaways on the Lake: Great location, food was average - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. More restaurant details. (585) 323-2943 Visit Website Map & Directions 244 Lake RdWebster, NY 14580. Shanghai Resort’s Castaway Grill & Bar. Castaway Bar and Kitchen is a unique restauraunt and cocktail bar located on 4th Ave in Kitsilano. (585) 323-1224. 2380 • Email: [email protected] in beautiful Chillicothe Illinois, Castaways is your number one stop for delicious pub food!. Ate even every crumb of crust. Webster. When it comes to waterfront restaurants, Castaway Bay offers two of the best options on Lake Erie! Learn more & enjoy outdoor dining in Sandusky, OH today!Castaways Chicago Menus. Castaways on the Lake: Beautiful weather and tasty food! - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Castaways cottages come in many different layouts to suit any party. Price range: $0 - $20. Brian, the beer tender, is a great guy and has a fun sense of humor. Lakeshore Dr. Castaways on the Lake: I can almost see Canada across the lake. 69 photos. Most beer gardens offer a view of the surrounding brick walls, the sites and sounds of the. Webster. 244 Lake Rd, Webster, NY 14580-1015. Castaways on. Immerse yourself in a culinary journey featuring the finest tastes, including regional oysters and market-fresh fish. Went in for drinks only. Specialties: seafood, steaks, sushi Full Bar 33 Beers on Tap Oldest restaurant on the island (1951) large menu, family owned and operated indoor waterfront, or outdoor seating live music 5 nights/week Established in 1951. 5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #3 of 4 restaurants in Cushing. Claim this business. Webster. Check-in time 4 p. Willoughby. m. Cuisines: American. Castaways on the Lake. Castaways on the Lake: Dinner with friends - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. •. Home; Food Menu; Other Menus. Webster Tourism Webster Hotels Webster Bed and Breakfast Webster Vacation Rentals Flights to WebsterCastaways on the Lake: View was Great, Food ok - See 318 traveler reviews, 62 candid photos, and great deals for Webster, NY, at Tripadvisor. Webster. This makes it a suitable spot for those looking to unwind or have a casual get-together with friends. Drink and dine outside (or under cover) directly on Lake Ontario with views of the Irondequoit Bay Outlet and spectacular sunsets (checkout the website video and Photo Gallery). Castaways on the Lake, Webster: See 318 unbiased reviews of Castaways on the Lake, rated 3. Castaways on the Lake, Webster (town), New York. Castaways on the Lake: This is a hidden jem of a place. B. Our Menu draws from Kirk’s Northeast Coast influences and blends local traditions with a Boston feel.